Temporary Jobs Are Leading This Recovery. Permanent Jobs Are Still Deciding.
Two numbers landed in the same fortnight this August, and they don't quite agree with each other. On 10 August, the KPMG and REC UK Report on Jobs announced that permanent placements had finally stopped falling, ending a slump that had run for 45 consecutive months, roughly since the market turned sour at the end of 2022. Eight days later, the Office for National Statistics published its own count and confirmed UK vacancies had slipped to 707,000, the lowest total outside the pandemic since 2014.
Both figures are accurate. Neither is the whole story on its own, which feels like a very British way for a recovery to begin: quietly, and with somebody immediately pointing out the flaws.
Look past the permanent-placement headline and the actual hero of the story is temporary work, which has spent most of the last four years being treated as recruitment's consolation prize. Temp billings rose for a fourth consecutive month in July, growing at close to their fastest rate in three years, and temporary vacancies increased for the first time in two years. Permanent hiring, by contrast, only stopped shrinking. Think of it less as a recovery and more as employers finally agreeing to stop apologising for not hiring.
That distinction matters more than it sounds like it should. CIPD's latest employer survey found only 57% of private-sector businesses plan to recruit at all in the next three months, and describes the wider mood as “low-hire, low-fire”, which is corporate-speak for “we're not really doing anything, but we'd like credit for the restraint.” Vacancies falling to 707,000, with 2.5 unemployed people for every one of them in April to June, sits comfortably alongside that caution. Employers appear willing to bring people in. They are simply not yet willing to promise those people a permanent future.
We're seeing the same pattern in the roles we recruit for. Businesses that would have signed off a permanent hire eighteen months ago are asking for contract or interim cover instead, not because the work has disappeared, but because nobody wants to be the one who signed off a permanent salary two months before conditions turn again. It's a reasonable instinct, even if it does let the finance director feel cautious and clever at the same time. It also means the first extra opportunities to appear this autumn are more likely to be temporary, project-based or fixed-term than advertised as permanent from day one.
That appetite for flexibility is about to collide with a government trying to regulate it out of workers' lives. A consultation on guaranteed hours, minimum shift notice and compensation for late-cancelled shifts closed on 25 August, and CIPD research found around two-thirds of affected employers expect the changes to raise their costs, with nearly half calling the rules difficult to implement. The policy is meant to give zero-hours and low-hours workers more security. Some employers appear to have read that as a challenge, and are reportedly considering the traditional response: buying that flexibility somewhere else instead, through agency labour or self-employed contractors who sit outside the new rules entirely. It's the workplace equivalent of being told to tidy your room and building an extension instead. For sectors that lean heavily on flexible or hourly staffing, that's worth watching closely over the next few months.
National statistics can tell you whether vacancies are rising or falling. They can't tell an individual business whether its next hire will be easy, and they certainly won't warn a data-centre developer, a submarine programme and a housing association that they're all quietly trying to poach the same electrical engineer this autumn. That's the thread running through most of what's happened since the last edition: flexibility, pay and skilled labour are all being renegotiated at once, and whichever side of the table you're sitting at, September is a reasonable moment to work out what you're actually negotiating for.
See you next month.